NEW YORK – Once hailed as a refreshing voice in late-night talk, Gutfeld! is now facing serious backlash from its own loyal audience. The reason? One name: Tyrus.

Known for his bold persona and strong presence, Tyrus — former pro wrestler and political commentator — is now being accused of turning Gutfeld! into his own personal platform. Frustrated fans say they only tune in for Greg Gutfeld’s opening monologue and promptly switch off when Tyrus starts talking.

“He doesn’t let anyone finish a sentence, always interrupts, always acts like he’s the smartest one in the room. I came for witty debates, not bullying,” one viral post with over 3,500 shares on X (formerly Twitter) reads.

Others joke that watching Tyrus dominate the panel feels more exhausting than dealing with hospital costs after a bad diagnosis.

From Funny Banter to Tense Interruptions. Gutfeld! gained popularity by blending sharp political commentary with humor, featuring regulars like Emily Compagno, Dave Landau, and of course, Tyrus.

But many viewers now say the roundtable discussions feel “tense and exhausting” as Tyrus constantly talks over others and dominates the conversation.

“It used to feel like a smart group of friends chatting. Now it’s like watching someone hijack the mic every night,” a Reddit user commented, comparing the stress of watching the show to dealing with private health insurance paperwork.

The fun, freewheeling debates that once defined the show have given way to a more combative atmosphere, with Tyrus often cutting off his fellow panelists and steering the discussion towards his own perspective, whether the other guests are ready or not.

Fans feel that the show, which was originally praised for its relaxed, witty atmosphere, has become more of a “Tyrus monologue” than a balanced conversation. Ratings Show Early Warning Signs. While Gutfeld! still leads among late-night political shows, media analysts are warning that the show is at risk of alienating its core viewership if it doesn’t make changes soon.

“Audiences can forgive a bad joke — but not the feeling of being forced to sit through one guy steamrolling everyone else,” said Nancy Field, a media analyst at MediaDecoder. “The show needs to find a way to regain the balance that made it so successful in the first place.”

Ratings for Gutfeld! have begun to show signs of a dip, especially in key demographics where the show once thrived. With more viewers turning off during Tyrus’s segments, the show could face a drop in engagement if changes aren’t made.

Much like failing to manage chronic illness, unresolved issues can quietly drain a show’s vitality until it’s too late.

Will Greg Take Action? So far, host Greg Gutfeld has remained silent amid growing backlash. As the face of the show, Gutfeld is in a unique position to address the concerns of his viewers. However, fans are making their demands loud and clear across social platforms, calling on the show to:

Limit Tyrus’s speaking time. Ensure equal airtime for all guests. Or in some cases — remove him altogether

The situation is rapidly becoming a dilemma for Gutfeld. Will he protect a long-time co-host and friend in Tyrus, or will he listen to fans who have voiced their concerns over the show’s current format? It’s the kind of calculated decision one might expect during a medical malpractice lawsuit — high stakes, careful moves, and lasting consequences.

The tension surrounding Tyrus’s dominance on the show has divided viewers—some continue to support him, appreciating his strong opinions and larger-than-life personality, while others feel his approach is overshadowing the entire point of the show.

For Gutfeld, who has always been known for his witty and engaging hosting style, this presents a unique challenge: balancing his co-host’s presence with the desires of the audience.

What Happens Next? The next few weeks will be crucial for Gutfeld! as the show faces increasing pressure to address the issues surrounding Tyrus’s role.

It’s a difficult balancing act — does Gutfeld choose to rein in Tyrus in order to restore the show’s original dynamic, or does he keep things as they are in the hopes of keeping the fiery energy intact?

Fans are watching closely. With increasing chatter across social media and growing concerns about the direction the show is taking, Gutfeld! faces a crossroads.

If it wants to maintain its dominance in late-night television, it will need to address these concerns head-on and recalibrate its approach to panel discussions — much like how expectant parents carefully plan their prenatal care to avoid complications down the line.

While the show remains a leader in its time slot, the growing backlash could threaten its future if the network fails to adjust.

Whether Gutfeld makes the bold decision to rein in his co-host or continues to let Tyrus dominate the airwaves will likely determine whether the show can hold onto its audience — or risk alienating the very viewers who helped it rise to prominence.

For now, one thing is clear: the next few episodes of Gutfeld! will be closely scrutinized as fans and critics alike eagerly await to see how this late-night drama unfolds.